American Idol 9: Top 12 (The Rolling Stone)

Last week, we said goodbye to Kathlyn Epperly, Lilly Scott, Todrick Hall, and Alex Lambert.  The top 12 will be doing the Rolling Stone.

Song Recap-3/9/10 & 3/11/10
Katie Stevens-"Breakaway" by Kelly Clarkson
Siohban Magnus-"House of The Rising Sun" by The Animals
Lacey Brown-"Love Song" by Brandi Carlile
Dibi Benami-"Rhiannon" by Fleetwood Mac
Paige Miles-"Smile"by Charlie Chaplin
Crystal Bowersox-"Give Me One Reason" by Tracy Chapman
Lee DeWyze-"Firefiles" by Owl City
Tim Urban-"Hallelujah" by Jeff Buckley
Andrew Garcia-"Genie In The Bottle" by Christina Aguilera
Casey James-"You'll Think For Me" by Keith Urban
Aaron Kelly-"I'm Already There" by Lonestar
Micheal Lynche-"This Woman's Work" by Maxwell


Michael Lynche-"Miss You" 1(866) 436-5701
-Awesome Performance!!!  Randy, Ellen, Kara liked his performance. Simon didn't like the dancing on the stage. Kudos to Ryan for sticking up for Michael.

Didi Benami-"Play with Fire" by1(866) 436-5702
-All the judges must be tone-deaf because I didn't like her performance. I think that all four judges need to re-watch her performance.

Casey James- "All Over Now" 1(866) 436-5703
-Simon didn't like performance.

Lacey Brown- "Ruby Tuesday" 1(866) 436-5704
-I didn't like her performance. Ellen, Kara, and Simon said that her performance is boring.

Andrew Garcia- Gimme Shelter 1(866) 436-5705
-Awesome performance!!! Randy said that it was pitchy performance. Ellen like his performance. Geez Simon stop with "Straight Up" Performance from Hollywood Week.

Katie Stevens-"Wild Horses" 1(866) 436-5706
- Randy and Ellen said the song was pitchy. Kara and Simon like her performance.

Tim Urban- Under My Thumb 1(866) 436-5707
-Boring Performance. Kara must be tone-deaf because I didn't like his performance.

Siohban Magnus-"Paint It Black" 1(866) 436-5708
-Oh My Goodness!!!

Lee DeWyze-"Beast of Burden"1(866) 436-5709
-Randy, Kara, and Simon liked his performance.

Paige Miles-"Honky Tonk Women"1(866) 436-5710
- I still didn't liked her performance.

Aaron Kelly-"Angie"1(866) 436-5711
-Please stop copying Ellen's hair style. The judges and I liked his performance.

Crystal Bowersox-"You Can't Always Get What You Want"1(866) 436-5712
- Sorry Crystal, I liked the Rolling Stone's version. I can't believe that Randy throw Siohban's performance underneath the bus.

Favorite Performances: Michael Lynche, Andrew Garcia, Siohban Magnus, Lee DeWyze, Aaron Kelly

Least Favorite Performance: Dibi Benami, Casey James, Lacey Brown, Tim Urban

Going Home on Wednesday's Night: Dibi Benami, Tim Urban, or Paige Miles