American Idol 10 (Top 12)

Last week, We say goodbye to Ashton Jones on March 10, 2011.  She sang When You Tell Me That You Me by Diana Ross and she didn't get the Judge Save by the judges. This week song theme is song from their birth year. Randy, Jennifer, Steven and Ryan said that tonight downloads is going to American Red Cross to help Japan.


Special Appearence: Carly Smithson, Kate Hudson, SYCD's Judges Tamyra and Mary Murphy


Song Recap-3/9/11
Lauren Aliana-Any Men of Mine (Shania Twain)
Casey Abrams-With A Little Help From My Friends (Joe Cocker)
Ashton Jones-When You Tell That You Me (Diana Ross)
Paul McDonald-Come Pick Me Up (Ryan Adams)
Pia Toscano-All By Myself (Celine Dion)
James Durbin-Maybe I'm Amazed (Paul McCartney)
Haley Reinhart-Blue (LeAnn Rimes)
Jacob Lusk-I Believe I Can Fly (R.Kelly)
Thia Megia-Smile(Michael Jackson)
Stefano Langone-Lately (Stevie Wonder)
Karen Rodriquez- I Could Fall In Love (Selena)
Scott McCreery-The River (Garth Brooks)
Namia Adedapo-Umbrella (Rihanna)


The Top 12 songs and remember to vote by phone, online, and text.


Naima Adadepo- What Love Got Do With It (Tina Turner)
Birth Year: 1984
Text: 5701
Judges Verdict
Steven: Loved her performance.
Jennifer: She want Naima to watch out on the pitchness in the song.
Randy: pitchy and vocal was all over the place during the song.
Twitter Feedback:

TeamThiaMegia Thia Megia Fan Club 

Jennifer not liking Naima. And Randy too" a mess"

Paul McDonald-I Guess That’s Why They Call It The Blues (Elton John)

Birth Year: 1984

Text: 5702
Judges Verdict
Steven: He love his sway and want him to watch his notes of the song.
Jennifer:  She didn't like his performance.
Randy: The notes were pitchy. He
Twitter Feedback:

LookToTheStarz Craig 

another bad performance

Thia Megia-Color of the wind (Vanessa Williams)

Birth Year:1995

Text: 5703
Judges Verdict
Steven:
Jennifer: She don't want her safe songs and want her to get out of comfort zone.
Randy:  The vocal was ok and wasn't special. He want her to take risk with her song choice.
Twitter Feedback:

Idol360 Idol360 

Thia Megia 1995 Colors Of The Wind. I think Thia will always be kind of boring. She has a nice voice, but I don't think it will sell records

James Durbin- I'll Be There For You (Bon Jovi)

Birth Year: 1989

Text: 5704
Judges Verdict
Steven:  Rich vine of inter crazy.
Jennifer: Amazing performance.
Randy: Few pitch issues and loved his performance
Twitter Feedback:

Irishgal719 NANCY 

James is really doing a good job tonight.

Haley Reinhart-I'm Your Baby, Tonight (Whitney Houston)

Birth Year: 1990

Text: 5705
Judges Verdict
Steven: want more blues in her performance
Jennifer: She look great.
Randy: confuse about her performance.
Twitter Feedback:

krummy09 Siobhan Magnus Fans 

Haley is a trainwreck


Stefano Langone-If You Don't Know Me By Now (Simply Red)
Birth Year: 1989
Text: 5706
Judges Verdict
Steven: Wonderful performance
Jennifer: Perfect song and perfect performance
Randy: Best performance of the night
Twitter Feedback:

cdnshannon Shannon 

Stefano is my fave so far!


Pia Toscano-Where Do Broken Heart Go (Whitney Houston)
Birth Year-1988
Text: 5707
Judges Verdict
Steven: Nail the song!!!
Jennifer: Love her performance.
Randy: Amazing vocals!!!
Twitter Feedback:

xoxo_ali Ali 

Pia is amazing! LOVE her voice!!

Scott McCreary-Can I Trust You With My Heart (Travis Traitt)

Birth Year:1993

Text: 5708
Judges Verdict
Steven: Very good
Jennifer: Love his performance
Randy: You did Travis Traitt proud.
Twitter Feedback:

Billboarddotcom Billboard 

Good golly miss molly -- Scotty McCreery, please sing an Elvis song. #Idol

Karen Rodriquez-Love Will Lead You Back (Taylor Dayne)

Birth Year: 1989

Text: 5709
Judges Verdict
Steven:
Jennifer: peform from your heart
Randy: Better like
Twitter Feedback:

LookToTheStarz Craig 

Karen has a good voice

Casey Abrams-Smell Like Teen Spirit (Nirvana)

Birth Year: 1991

Text: 5710
Judges Verdict
Steven: Crazy and talent
Jennifer: Didn't like his performance
Randy: Like his performance but want more.
Twitter Feedback:

peacefrogdesign Froggy 

I like Casey because he is fucking insane. That is all.

Lauren Aliana- I'm The Only One (Melissa Etheridge)

Birth Year: 1994
Text: 5711
Judges Verdict
Steven: like her performance
Jennifer: Very nice performance
Randy: like her performance and she is back.
Twitter Feedback:

Irishgal719 NANCY 

Lauren is cute and has a nice voice

Jacob Lusk-Alone (Heart)
Birt Year: 1987

Text: 5712
Judges Verdict
Steven: You on fire
Jennifer: so amazing performance
Randy: very nice performance!!
Twitter Feedback:

xoxo_ali Ali 

i love this song!!!!!!

My Feedback


My favorite performance: James Durbin, Stefano Langone, Pia Toscano, Casey Abrams. Lauren Aliana, and Jacob Lusk.


My least favorite performance: Paul McDonald, Thia Megia, Haley Reinhart


50/50 Club: Naima Adadepo and Karen Rodriquez